
Best Medicine Season 1: A Quirky Medical Dramedy Worth Starting
Best Medicine
Early impressions of a medical dramedy that nails the balance between a difficult doctor, a funny ensemble and cases that matter.
Other / not applicable
The verdict
A funny, warm medical dramedy with an engaging ensemble. These are early impressions, not a verdict on the completed season.
The full review
I’ve only recently started watching the first season of Best Medicine, and it’s already a show I enjoy sharing at home. A difficult doctor, a town full of people who are interesting without him, and medical cases with room for comedy: it’s a combination I was glad to find. These are early impressions, not a verdict on the whole season. So far, I’m happy to keep going.
A good doctor with a terrible bedside manner
Martin Best, played by Josh Charles, leaves a surgical career in Boston to become a general practitioner in a coastal fishing community he knew as a child. That’s the premise of FOX’s adaptation of Doc Martin. Martin is good at the technical part of medicine. Putting people at ease is something else entirely.
I like the gap between those two abilities. A doctor can want to get straight to the facts while the person sitting across from him needs to be heard before they can explain what’s wrong. You don’t need to work especially hard to find comedy in that mismatch. Nor does the person who needs some patience have to be the joke.
The townspeople aren’t there just to react to Martin
Martin gives the show its central friction, but the people around him are as much a reason to watch. The cast includes Abigail Spencer as Louisa Gavin, Annie Potts as Aunt Sarah, Josh Segarra as Sheriff Mark Mylow and Cree as Elaine Denton. It’s the combination that makes the town interesting, not just the fact that the doctor is difficult.
That matters in a case-of-the-week show. The patient and the immediate problem can change, but the regulars make each new episode feel like a return. A prickly lead could get tiring if everyone else existed only to look offended. Here, part of the fun is seeing who gets to be the peculiar one in a given situation. It doesn’t always have to be Martin.
Enough drama to make the comedy count
The cases give each episode a problem to solve. That leaves room for a running story about the town without making every episode feel like homework for the next one. I can enjoy the case in front of me while getting more attached to the people I’ll see again.
What I most enjoy is the balance. Some medical shows turn almost every conversation into a crisis. Some comedies get so determined to keep the jokes coming that the characters can never seem genuinely worried. Best Medicine lets people be funny without treating their problems as disposable. I can enjoy the absurdity of an interaction and still care how it ends.
It also makes for a good shared watch. The appeal doesn’t depend on everyone liking the same character or even finding the same moments funny. A show with an ensemble this engaging gives you something to talk about besides whether the doctor got the diagnosis right.
Early verdict: If you like a small-town series with a strong ensemble and medical cases that can be funny without turning into sketches, give Best Medicine a try. I’m not ready to judge the whole season, but I already look forward to spending another episode with these people.

