Illustration of Jamaican escovitch fish with pickled vegetables and fried festival dumplings.

One Love Jamaican Kitchen Review: I’m Going Back for the Fish and Festival

One Love Jamaican Restaurant

A Jamaican in Japan explains why the escovitch fish, festival and familiar dishes at One Love are worth coming back for.

Other / not applicable

Author rating4 / 5

The verdict

A Jamaican meal I enjoy coming back for, especially the escovitch fish and festival.

The full review

When I want Jamaican food in Japan, I’m not always looking for somebody’s clever take on jerk chicken. Sometimes I want fried fish and festival. I want to order rice and peas without having to explain what the peas are. And I want oxtail to be an actual choice, not something I have to make at home if I’m in the mood for it. That’s why I keep going back to One Love.

I’m Jamaican and live in Kanagawa. I’ve had Jamaican-inspired food in Japan, and I have nothing against a kitchen making something new with familiar flavors. One Love stands out for a different reason. It serves the kind of meal I’d be happy to sit down to back home, or at a Jamaican restaurant in New York, Miami or London. What I recognize is less a single flavor than the way a whole table of dishes fits together

Start with the fish and festival

Fried fish is my order. Escovitch, if you haven’t had it, is whole fried fish with a vinegar-based dressing and pickled vegetables. The sharp dressing is part of the point: it cuts through the richness of the fried fish rather than covering it up. Festival is a slightly sweet fried dumpling. I like them together because I want something different from the next bite, not just a side that takes up room on the plate.

If you’re used to ordering jerk chicken whenever you see a Jamaican menu, this is a good chance to try something else. Take your time if you order the fish, especially if you’re not accustomed to eating it whole. The restaurant’s listed menu describes the fish and festival as separate items. Check what comes with your order rather than assuming the sides are included.

There’s more than one good way to order

Oxtail, jerk chicken, and rice and peas are the other dishes we’ve ordered. If I were bringing somebody new to Jamaican cooking, I’d suggest two mains for the table rather than having everybody order the same thing. Jerk chicken makes a good first choice, but putting it next to oxtail shows how different two Jamaican dishes can be. One makes its case with jerk seasoning; the other is about what a long stew does to the meat and gravy. Rice and peas makes sense with either.

There’s a useful distinction here. A restaurant can serve a good plate of jerk chicken and still not be where I go when I want a Jamaican dinner. What brings me back to One Love is having enough to choose from that I don’t have to order the same meal every time. I just happen to want the fish and festival often enough that it usually wins.

Worth going back for

There’s a particular pleasure in finding a restaurant abroad that serves food you know well. You can judge it on the same terms you would anywhere else. You don’t have to give it extra credit just for being far from Jamaica. One Love is a place I enjoy returning to because it serves dishes I actually want to eat, in combinations that make sense to me.

Conclusion

If you’re curious about Jamaican cooking beyond jerk, One Love is a good place to start. If you already know what you miss, go straight to that. For me, it’s the fish and festival.

Leave a comment